The Department of Homeland Security’s review of state voter rolls has landed in Pennsylvania, and the state’s response so far has been resistance rather than cooperation. That resistance is playing out against the backdrop of Chester County’s own documented election failures, and a set of county level numbers that haven’t gotten much attention yet.
This summer, in July, DHS Secretary Markwayne Mullin sent letters to election officials in California, New Jersey, Nevada, and Pennsylvania, citing a preliminary federal review that identified more than 250,000 potential noncitizen voter registrations across the four states. In Pennsylvania 14,576 were identified. Mullin asked each state to work with DHS to verify the records and said officials who declined to cooperate could face consequences, including fines.
Pennsylvania’s Secretary of the Commonwealth, Al Schmidt, a Republican appointed by Democratic Gov. Josh Shapiro, responded with a letter of his own. Schmidt asked DHS to explain its methodology and disclose its data sources before the state takes any further action. He noted that DHS’s SAVE database has a documented history of returning inaccurate citizenship information, and that the federal government has not explained how it obtained social security numbers for a voter roll analysis, since Pennsylvania’s public rolls don’t include that data.
To date, Pennsylvania has not turned over voter roll data to DHS. The state joins California, Nevada, and New Jersey in that posture, and all four are currently defending those decisions against Department of Justice lawsuits seeking the same records.
A separate, county level data point complicates the issue. Multiple election integrity focused citizens have spent recent weeks pulling Pennsylvania’s non-juror lists, the county by county rosters of people who were summoned for jury duty and reported back that they were ineligible because they aren’t citizens. Those lists exist because state law requires jury pools to be drawn from comprehensive rolls that include noncitizens who hold a PennDOT ID, pay taxes, or receive state assistance. When a noncitizen receives a jury summons, their name is recorded on a public non-juror list maintained by the county courts.
The subsequent review of Chester County’s non-juror list found more than 3,500 names on it, one of the larger counts among the counties examined, alongside Dauphin, Westmoreland, and several others. Unlike the DHS figures, which Pennsylvania officials have publicly questioned, the non-juror lists are county court records generated independently of the federal review, and the underlying data source, jury summons responses, is not in dispute.
That comparison against the county’s active voter rolls has already been run. Felice Fein reported on July 30 that Chester County’s disqualified juror list was cross-checked against public voter registration records, and approximately 250 people who had claimed noncitizen status to get out of jury duty were found registered to vote in the county. Some had never cast a ballot, but Fein reported that many had voted, either by mail or in person.
Republican Chester County Commissioner Eric Roe said he would personally review each flagged name, both as a member of the county’s Election Board and its newly formed Voter Registration Commission.
The timing matters locally. Chester County spent the past year working through its own election administration failure, a poll book error that omitted 75,076 registered voters from printed lists at all 230 precincts on Election Day 2025, forcing more than 12,600 voters onto provisional ballots. An outside investigation, delivered in January, attributed the error to two inexperienced employees who selected the wrong option in the state’s voter registration system, compounded by what investigators called insufficient safeguards, training, supervision, and verification controls in the county’s election office. The report found no evidence of intentional wrongdoing.
That history is part of why the current standoff draws local interest. Chester County has already acknowledged, through an independent investigation it commissioned itself, that its voter list processes lacked basic verification controls. Whether that same office has the capacity to reconcile a 3,500 name non-juror list against its voter rolls, or has done so, is an open question county officials have yet to address publicly.
The political dimension is also worth tracking as Pennsylvania heads into November. Stacy Garrity, the Republican nominee for governor, has said she would fully cooperate with DHS’s request for voter roll access, telling a Harrisburg television audience that Pennsylvania should “hand over the rolls” if state officials are confident there’s no fraud to find. That puts her at odds with Schmidt, a fellow Republican, whose office is currently the one declining to do so. Shapiro, running for reelection, has said the state takes all allegations of illegal voting seriously while noting that confirmed instances of noncitizen voting remain rare; a 2019 state review found 544 potentially illegal ballots out of more than 93 million cast between 2000 and 2017.
While none of the current figures, DHS’s or outside watchdog’s, legally establish that noncitizen votes were actually cast in Chester County, they do indicate that there may be foul play. What is established are two independent data sets, a federal matching review and a county’s own jury records, both pointing at Pennsylvania, especially Chester County, as a place where the voter rolls warrant a closer look. Given the county’s recent history with its poll books, that closer look would seem to be in its own interest, regardless of how the DHS-Schmidt dispute over methodology gets resolved.
Ada Nestor is a writer and conservative commentator who lives in Chester County with her family. She publishes My Reflections from the Edge on Substack which is frequently found on the Top 100 Rising in U.S. Politics.

