On Sept. 15, the same week Pennsylvania counties began mailing ballots for the November election, State Sen. Carolyn Comitta and Rep. Chris Pielli each sent West Chester-area residents a press release congratulating themselves for delivering state grant money to their district. Rep. Melissa Shusterman sent a third.
All three cited the same pot of funding. All three thanked each other by name. None of them cast a single vote to approve a dollar of it.
The money in question comes from the Commonwealth Financing Authority, a seven-member state board that approves grants from gaming revenue, water and sewer funds, and the state’s transportation accounts. Three of those seats belong to the governor’s own cabinet: the secretaries of Community and Economic Development, the Budget, and Banking and Securities. The other four are legislative appointees, one each chosen by the Senate majority caucus, the Senate minority caucus, the House majority caucus, and the House minority caucus. Approval takes five of seven votes, and at least four of those votes have to come from the legislative appointees.
Carolyn Comitta is not Senate Democratic leadership. Jay Costa holds that title. Chris Pielli is not House leadership of either party. Neither of them sits on the CFA board. Neither of them casts a vote on whether a single one of these grants gets approved. What they do is send out a press release once the board acts, because the money happens to be going to a municipality inside their district lines. “Announced” and “secured” are the verbs their offices choose. “Live inside the district that got picked” is what actually happened.
Here’s what went out that day. Comitta’s newsroom announced funding for fire, police, and 911 call center upgrades in Coatesville, Oxford, Valley, and Willistown. Pielli’s release, $2.2 million total, included $400,000 for Chester County’s 911 call center software and equipment, and closed with this line: “I’m proud to work with community partners, my staff and Sen. Carolyn Comitta to continue bringing home these and other grants.” Shusterman’s release, $2.47 million, covered Willistown Township too, and quoted Comitta directly on the subject of her own committee work: “Strong emergency response and public safety services are integral to a strong quality of life in our communities.”
Three press releases, three separate legislative offices, one township showing up in two of them, one senator quoted in a colleague’s release about her own subject matter. That is not three offices independently noticing the same board vote on the same afternoon. That is a script, and everyone involved knew their line.
Comitta and Pielli have been running this act for a while. In January, Pielli’s office announced $1.12 million in water infrastructure money and “credited collaboration with the authority and state Sen. Carolyn Comitta for helping secure the grants.” A month earlier, announcing a storm sewer grant, Pielli thanked “state Sen. Carolyn Comitta, PennDOT Secretary Mike Carroll and Gov. Josh Shapiro for their support.” Days before that, on more than $3 million in water infrastructure funding, he said he was “glad to join state Senator Carolyn Comitta in supporting this funding to improve water infrastructure within our legislative districts.”
Same senator’s name, nearly the same sentence, release after release, going back to at least December 2025. Neither of them has ever cast a CFA vote in that stretch. What they have done is find a way to attach their names to state money every few weeks like clockwork, using language built to sound like personal effort.
Comitta and Pielli didn’t invent this. They’re just the local face of it. The same 24-to-48-hour window that produced their Chester County cluster also produced grant releases from Rep. Nikki Rivera in Lancaster ($1.7 million), Rep. Joe Ciresi in Montgomery County ($1.8 million), Rep. Carol Kazeem in Delaware County ($2.4 million), Rep. Nate Davidson outside Harrisburg ($4.36 million), and a Philadelphia delegation release totaling $43 million. One of Rivera’s releases wasn’t even bylined to her own office. It was bylined straight to the “Pennsylvania House Democratic Caucus.”
That detail matters more than any individual dollar figure in the story, actually. It means the caucus itself, as an institution, is running part of this operation. Comitta and Pielli aren’t two legislators who happened to time their press releases well. They’re plugging into a communications machine built to make an entire caucus look like it’s delivering for constituents in the exact week those constituents start filling out their ballots.
The Pennsylvania Department of State confirmed that mail ballots for the Nov. 3 general election started going out statewide the week of Sept. 14. Comitta’s five-release run landed Sept. 11 through 15.
Pielli has a direct reason to want his name in front of voters right now. His seat is on the ballot this November, same as it is every two years, and his 156th District has flipped parties more than once since the 1970s. It was Comitta’s own House seat before she moved up to the Senate, and it isn’t safe just because Democrats have held it since 2017. A flood of good-news press with his name on it, timed to the week ballots arrive, is exactly what a nervous incumbent in a swing-ish district would want.
Comitta’s own seat runs through 2028. She isn’t on this ballot at all. Which makes her participation the more interesting piece, not the less interesting one. She isn’t spending a taxpayer-funded press operation to save her own job. She’s spending it to make her party’s entire ticket, governor’s race included, look like it’s delivering, in the exact week some residents start deciding how to vote. That isn’t constituent service. That’s a state office being used as a campaign surrogate, on the public’s dime, for candidates who aren’t even her.
This isn’t the first time the CFA’s own process has drawn scrutiny. Spotlight PA and WHYY reported back in 2019 that the board’s public meetings are largely ceremonial, that the real deliberation happens behind closed doors, and that the Commonwealth Foundation’s Andrew Abramczyk went on record calling it deliberation “intentionally pushed into secret.” Six years later, nothing about that process has changed. What has changed is how efficiently Comitta, Pielli, and the rest of their caucus have learned to turn a closed-door board’s decisions into their own open-door campaign material.
Voters in West Chester, West Goshen, and East Goshen are going to open their mailboxes this month and find a ballot in one hand and a stack of “Comitta Announces” and “Pielli Announces” mailers in the other. They should know what they’re actually looking at. Not two legislators who fought for their community. Two legislators who read a press release out loud after someone else already decided.
Ada Nestor is a writer and conservative commentator who lives in Chester County with her family. She publishes My Reflections from the Edge on Substack which is frequently found on the Top 100 Rising in U.S. Politics.

