Could Alec Bohm‘s future be in the big apple?

According to FanSided‘s Robert Murray, “Bohm’s camp met with at leas the Yankees and Mets, among others” during this week’s GM meetings in Las Vegas.

There had been some question about the Yankees and Bohm. Jon Heyman of The New York Post reported Wednesday that “the Yankees are showing interest in Bohm, and the feeling is believed to be mutual.” However, Brendan Kuty of The Athletic reported later in the day that “a source briefed on the situation said that the sides hadn’t met.”

In theory, Bohm could get at-bats against left-handed pitching at both third base and first base, while also getting occasional DH at-bats when Giancarlo Stanton is inevitably injured. The Yankees do have Ryan McMahon under contract for 2027 at third base, but he posted just a 76 OPS+ this past year (100 is the league average) and is pretty much unplayable against lefties. Luis García Jr. is penciled in as their first baseman, but hits righties much better than lefties and also can play second base. Ben Rice is probably more of a DH than a first baseman, while Paul Goldschmidt is a free agent. You can at least see the fit for Bohm in the Bronx.

As for the Mets, president of baseball operations David Stearns needs to get things right this offseason to save his job after consecutive disappointing seasons. The Mets do have Bo Bichette under contract to play third base, although he could conceivably shift to second base if Bohm signed. It’s also worth noting that Bichette can opt out of his deal next winter. Plus, with Jared Young at first base and Jorge Polanco at DH, the Mets would have plenty of other spots to utilize Bohm at even if Bichette is at third base.

It would be ironic for Bohm to end up on the Mets considering his infamous “I fucking hate this place” game in
April of 2022 came against the Mets:

The beauty is going to be in the eyes of the beholder with Bohm.

On one hand, he’s driven in 88 or more runs in three of the last four seasons. Almost all of his home runs go over 400 feet, so it wouldn’t be hard for a team to convince themselves that a change of scenery could help to unlock more with the 30-year-old.

On the other hand, Bohm hasn’t hit more than 20 home runs in seven MLB seasons, and while he has improved generally as a defender at third base, he posted minus-10 defensive runs saved and minus-eight outs above average at third base this past year. He probably doesn’t hit for enough power to justify a full-time move to first base, but that may very well be his best position.

Over on Bleacher Report, I predicted that Bohm would land a two-year/$30 million deal with the chance to opt out and return to free agency after 2027. My thought was that he would do better in a smaller market, although his girlfriend — ESPN talent Erin Kate Dolan — is local, so it’s possible he may prefer to stay in this region of the country. Either New York team would give him that chance.

In any event, if you saw how much Dave Dombrowski talked up Aidan Miller this week, it doesn’t seem that Bohm will be back with the Phillies in 2027.

Read More Phillies Content From OnPattison

  1. Will Dave Dombrowski be desperate enough to give huge contract to a reliever?
  2. Japanese outlet says Phillies are interested in Teruaki Sato
  3. Report: Trea Turner, Brandon Marsh ‘available’; Bryce Harper, Kyle Schwarber won’t be moved
  4. Phillies reportedly interested in versatile veteran infielder
  5. If not Suzuki or Arozarena, these are the other free agent outfield options for Phillies to consider
  6. We think we’ve figured out who bought the ‘cursed’ Ben Simmons/Nick Castellanos house
  7. What would the Phillies have to give up to sign free agent with qualifying offer?
  8. Seiya Suzuki or Randy Arozarena, who would be a better fit for Phillies?
  9. What free-agent options do Phillies have to upgrade backup catcher?
  10. Here’s the Phillies record by uniform in 2026