Polls open at 7 a.m. Tuesday, and while most voters will be preoccupied with the governor’s race, residents of three Chester County municipalities get a second job on their ballots: deciding how many people should run their local government, and whether to approve a rewrite of a township charter that has gone untouched since the 1970s.
There is no countywide question. The county’s list of local referendums, last updated September 14, has exactly three entries, and each one appears only on ballots in its own municipality.
Malvern wants fewer elected officials. East Whiteland wants more. Tredyffrin would like to know if you can approve forty changes with a single filled-in oval.
East Whiteland: Three Supervisors Were a Problem, So Try Five
The ballot question is short enough to read at a red light: “Should two (2) additional supervisors be elected to serve in this Township?” The board currently has three members, elected at large to six-year terms. A yes vote makes it five.
The reason this is on the ballot at all is a 1.5 million-square-foot data center planned for the 79-acre former Cyprus Foote Mineral property, a Superfund site on the line between East and West Whiteland. The project won early township approvals in 2018 and 2024. When the developers sought to expand it and update their plans this year, residents turned up in force, and a group of them spent the summer collecting enough signatures to put the size of the board to a vote. Organizer Jessica Larkin has said the aim is more balanced representation and a wider range of perspectives on the next project like this one.
The developers have since dropped the redesign after the outcry and decided to build the plan that was already approved. As preliminary construction began, they were issued two stop work orders over permitting concerns, and a Chester County judge earlier this year quashed an attempt by residents to appeal the land use. In September the supervisors passed an ordinance regulating data centers, but Philadelphia magazine reports the new rules will not apply to this project.
Then, on October 20, a residents’ group called East Whiteland United sent an eight-page notice of intent to sue. It names the township, its three supervisors, and the developers, Green Fig and Sentinel Data Centers, and demands that the group’s concerns be addressed “immediately and substantially.” According to MyChesCo, the notice cites a letter from Aqua America saying it could not meet the project’s water needs, building permit applications that drop the 20-foot basements in two approved buildings without a revised land development plan, and an environmental assessment the group calls incomplete or inaccurate. Those are the group’s allegations, not findings by a court. No lawsuit has been filed, and the notice has not overturned any approval. The township manager declined to comment, and the board chair and a developer representative had not responded when the Inquirer reported on the notice.
Which raises the question of what two more supervisors could and could not do. The three sitting supervisors, who are the named defendants, are the ones who decide how the township answers that notice. And based on how other Pennsylvania townships have handled the same referendum, new seats are filled at the next municipal election and not right away. Old Lycoming voters approved an expansion in November 2024, and the new supervisors were to be elected in 2025 and begin serving in January 2026. Donegal Township voters approved theirs in 2016, and a supervisor was elected to the five-member board in 2017.
If East Whiteland follows that pattern, the two new seats would go on the 2027 ballot and take office in January 2028.
So a yes vote would not change who sits at the table for the response to this notice, the stop work orders, or the permit fights now under way. It would change who sits there afterward, for later plan changes, enforcement decisions, and the next developer who shows up with a site plan and a lawyer. Supporters are betting that two more votes means two more people who ran on exactly this grievance.
Malvern: Seven Council Seats for 3,400 People
Malvern’s question runs the opposite direction. Shall the borough’s Home Rule Charter be amended to cut council from seven members to five, effective January 3, 2028? If yes wins, voters elect two council members in 2027 instead of four, and three in 2029. Nobody currently serving loses a seat early. The three members whose terms are not up in 2027 keep them through January 2, 2030.
This did not come from the council. County spokesman Andrew Kreider told Philadelphia magazine that a group of residents filed the petition on July 29 with roughly 243 signatures from registered Malvern voters, and that it was facially compliant and went unchallenged. The Inquirer reports the group is bipartisan and includes a former mayor, a former council president, and a zoning hearing board chairman.
Petition leader Danny Fruchter argues a smaller board would be more efficient and easier to staff. Malvern is about one square mile with roughly 3,400 residents, volunteers are getting scarce, and council members are limited to two consecutive terms. In Fruchter’s words, “neither party, in anybody’s memory, has come up with four qualified candidates.” He also points out that neighboring East Whiteland and Willistown get by with fewer elected officials.
Which leaves two neighboring municipalities, asked the same week how many elected officials is the right number, arriving at five from opposite directions. The case against Malvern’s version is the one that follows every proposal to cut seats: fewer seats means fewer voices, and on a five-member council three votes settle everything. The borough has run on seven since its charter was adopted in 2008, when it had about 3,100 residents. It has since added roughly 320 people and is now asking to lose two seats.
Tredyffrin: Forty Changes, One Oval
Then there is Tredyffrin, where the Home Rule Charter amendment runs to 40 numbered changes inside a single question. The ballot wording in the county’s official list goes on for the better part of a page. A yes approves all of it. A no rejects all of it. There is no oval for “yes, but leave the auditor alone.”
Much of it is housekeeping, and board chairman David Miller says as much. The charter was last revised in the 1970s. A 12-member charter review committee recommended the package and the board approved it. The effort started with a practical gap: members still join some meetings by video, and the charter never explicitly allowed that. The amendment lets a quorum be established in person or electronically. It also drops printing requirements for things like loose-leaf compilations and copies of the township’s general laws, since that material is online for free. Other changes require roll call votes on ordinances and resolutions, move agenda availability from eight hours before a meeting to 24, make meeting minutes free to the public, and update the nondiscrimination language.
The pay item reads oddly. The ballot says supervisor compensation would be amended from $1,500 to $3,000 per year. Miller told the Inquirer the vote would not raise anyone’s pay, because the increase was made in the 1980s and the charter simply never caught up. So for decades the document has said one number while the paychecks said another, and the fix is to ask voters to bless the paperwork.
Some of the 40 are not housekeeping, and these are the ones a township should probably have broken out into their own items to approve:
- Item 12 abolishes the elected auditor and replaces the post with an appointed, outside, independent auditor. The ballot text does not say who makes the appointment. Philadelphia magazine notes the township already hires the independent firm that performs the annual audit.
- Item 13 deletes the article creating an elected tax collector. Both the Inquirer and Philadelphia magazine report the township already handles collection through third parties or staff.
- Item 14 removes the residency requirement for the township manager. The ballot question itself mentions only the manager. The county’s plain-language explanation adds the Superintendent of Police, and Miller told the Inquirer the board has been able to waive the requirement and often has.
- Item 16 removes the requirement to notify neighboring property owners directly when a zoning amendment applies to only a small part of the township.
- Items 26 and 28 end the requirement to advertise the preliminary budget, though it must still be discussed and acted on at a public meeting and posted online, and stop requiring the final budget to be adopted by ordinance.
Plenty of these may be perfectly sensible, and the township says it already operates this way in several cases. Some of the notice rules were written for a world where the newspaper was how you found out what your township was up to. But a board that wants a painless yes from voters has put the elected auditor and the zoning notice rule in the same oval as the loose-leaf binders, and then asked everyone to take the whole thing or leave it.
Miller says the township held several public meetings during the drafting over the past year and attendance was low, and that questions have picked up as sample ballots circulate. That is fairly common. People often miss the notifications about meetings until the ballot with the proposed changes is sitting in front of them.
If you live in one of these three places, read your sample ballot before Tuesday. The Tredyffrin question in particular is not something to decode in a booth with a line forming behind you. Voters everywhere else in the county get a shorter ballot and none of this homework.
Sources
- Official List of Referendum Questions, November 3, 2026 General Election (Chester County, updated Sept. 14)
- Some Chester County voters will decide on the number of elected municipal officials, The Philadelphia Inquirer, Oct. 27, 2026
- Residents give notice of intent to sue East Whiteland and developer over 1.5 million square foot data center project, The Philadelphia Inquirer, Oct. 20, 2026
- East Whiteland Data Center Faces New Lawsuit Threat, MyChesCo, Oct. 22, 2026
- Your Suburban Ballot Questions, Explained, Philadelphia Magazine, Oct. 22, 2026
- Old Lycoming Township supervisor resigns, referendum to increase number of supervisors from three to five tentatively passes, Sun-Gazette, Nov. 2024
- Pennsylvania Supreme Court opinion, Martin v. Donegal Township (J-29-2024)

